A watchdog that cannot keep up risks turning a legal right into a theoretical one The Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO) has acknowledged that complaints may now take around 40 weeks simply to be assigned to a case officer. When added to the statutory process — 20 working days for a response and up to 40…
When a vehicle is reported stolen, most people assume the legal position is straightforward: the vehicle belongs to the person who reported it stolen, and anyone found in possession of it must simply surrender it. In reality, the situation can be far more complicated. A police crime report records an allegation of theft, but it…
When Allegations Start to Look Like Evidence A crime reference number confirms that something was reported. It does not confirm that the crime actually happened. Yet within vehicle theft claims, crime numbers and PNC “Lost or Stolen” markers are often treated as if they validate the allegation. In a recent case, a police review concluded:…
In a recent case, a senior reviewing officer recorded doubt that a vehicle theft had occurred. The crime remains recorded. This is not about one force. It raises a wider issue: Crime reports and crime reference numbers confirm that an allegation was recorded. They do not confirm that the allegation was verified. In many cases,…
Recent Parliamentary Questions on the National Vehicle Crime Intelligence Service (NaVCIS) were intended to clarify how this body is funded and governed. The Government’s answer was familiar: ‘NaVCIS is funded by industry partners, including finance and leasing companies, insurers and hauliers’. However, this broad description raises as many questions as it answers. What remains unclear?…
A recurring issue in vehicle theft cases is not recovery, but what happens afterwards. In a recent case, a stolen vehicle was recovered, albeit damaged and released by police on 5th January 2026, indicating that enquiries at the scene and forensic examination had been completed sufficiently to allow its return. A second vehicle stolen at…
Read the Form First! If you are applying for a police collision report for insurance or civil litigation purposes, a simple status enquiry could cost you. In at least one force area, the disclosure form states that: ‘Full disclosure will not be provided until a specified future date’. If you submit an email to check…
What is an “Enforced Subject Access Request”? Section 184 of the Data Protection Act 2018 creates a criminal offence known as “enforced subject access.” It is occasionally misunderstood. What Section 184 Actually Does Section 184 makes it an offence for a person to: A “relevant record” is narrowly defined as: Both elements must be present:…
We are frequently told that “relay theft” is becoming the norm for modern vehicles. But how certain are we? In many reported vehicle removals, there is no forensic evidence establishing precisely how the vehicle was started or driven away. Yet the explanation often quickly becomes “security bypass” or “electronic compromise.” Before concluding that modern vehicle…
A Risk in the UK Automotive Market Recent events involving GVE London have brought renewed attention to a longstanding concern: the potential pitfalls of ‘Sale or Return’ (SOR) agreements. This incident is not isolated. At CMA, we are investigating traders whose conduct has ended in dispute or financial loss – raising critical questions about the…
