| |

Is the NPCC Listening and Learning?

I welcomed the First-tier Tribunal’s description of me as “a sincere and intelligent witness”. The hearing lasted one morning. I had limited opportunity to question the NPCC’s witness about the assertions I disputed, but I was able to draw attention to the lack of documents produced to support them.

In paragraphs 46 and 47, the Tribunal recognised my longstanding interest in vehicle crime and the time I had spent trying to understand how the relevant systems work. It found that I genuinely wanted to obtain information and believed that further scrutiny could improve policy and practice. It found no malice, hostility, desire to harass the NPCC or its staff, or personal grudge.

My concern is what supported the specific assertions about my conduct and motives in the witness statement signed with a statement of truth by the head of the National Police Freedom of Information and Data Protection Unit, Ashleigh Beney. I dispute those assertions.

I have asked the NPCC what evidence the witness relied on and what checks were made before signing. I still await a substantive answer. First-tier Tribunal reasons, paragraphs 46–50.

A suspicion circulated without my knowledge

In June 2024, the NPCC’s Central Referral Unit (CRU) named me in a circular (603/2024) and recorded a suspicion that I was “keeping requests private” on WhatDoTheyKnow. Odd; my requests are on view, I have never kept a request private on WDTK.

When I asked what supported the suspicion, the NPCC said it held no recorded information within the scope of my request.

I raised the issues with the NPCC. Jon Vale, a chief inspector, Staff Officer to CC Gavin Stephens (NPCC Chair) & Staff Officer to ACO Gemma Stannard (Head of NPCC Strategic Hub), directed me to the Metropolitan Police Service (MPS). I set out my concerns to the MPS.

The MPS outcome report found the service unacceptable on three of the four issues and identified ‘organisational learning‘. On the remaining issue, its outcome referred to “limited information” bearing on the above suspicion.

What information did the MPS see, and how does it square with the NPCC’s response? The Met has yet to tell me what it relied on.

Supported by the outcome, I put my original questions back to Jon Vale and Gavin Stephens. However, the questions remain unanswered. This is the loop I have found myself in:

  1. I ask the NPCC to explain the basis for the circular.
  2. I get no substantive answer and complain to the MPS.
  3. The MPS finds shortcomings and identifies organisational learning.
  4. I return to the NPCC with the original questions – at ‘1’ above and progress to ‘2’…

Who is examining the signed statement?

Separately, I raised concerns about Ms Beney’s ‘statement of truth’ endorsed document. The MPS told me that Hampshire was the appropriate authority for my complaint about the signed statement because Ms. Beney is a Hampshire Constabulary employee. The MPS said it would take no further action on that complaint.

However, Hampshire police recorded the complaint and then closed it, saying that a case being handled by the MPS was “likely” to address the substance of my concerns.

I have asked Hampshire to identify that case and say which allegations, if any, the MPS agreed to examine. I have also asked the MPS to confirm whether it is considering any of the disputed assertions in the statement. I have yet to receive a substantive answer from either constabulary.

A service that learns

Opening the NPCC–APCC Summit on 17 November, Chief Constable Gavin Stephens called for “A police service that listens. A service that learns.” Summit address.

I have written to him again. A straightforward way to demonstrate what those words mean in practice:

  • What did the NPCC receive from the MPS by way of ‘organisational learning‘
  • What did the NPCC do with it, and
  • Who will now answer the questions that led to the complaint?

Chronology & Detail: Why did the NPCC make and circulate adverse claims about me?


Further reporting and source documents

18/10/2026 – FoIA request in progress: ‘Recording and use of requester information by NPCC’. This ‘concerns the NPCC Central Referral Unit and arises from matters recently reported nationally regarding the recording and use of requester information in the handling of Freedom of Information requests. It refers to the following article:

01/10/2025 – BBC: ‘Police unit blocking FOI requests U-turns on promised reforms‘

06/03/2025 – Democracy for Sale: ‘journalists targeted by secretive police unit‘

06/03/2025 – BBC: – Police unit dubbed ‘authoritarian censor‘

14/12/2023 – Cabinet Office: the FOI Clearing House Review

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *